Best Vegan Ice Cream of 2025: AI-Powered Rankings

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams Texas Sheet Cake

6.7/10Fair

6th

8th

So Delicious Wondermilk Vanilla

6.4/10Fair

8th

12th

Oatly Vanilla

6.3/10Fair

9th

13th

NadaMoo! Cookies & Creme

1st

So Delicious Chocolate Cookies 'n' Cream

1st

Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Phish Food

1st

Jeni's Vegan Lemon Bar

1st

Van Leeuwen Sicilian Pistachio

6.1/10Fair

2nd

10.

So Delicious Salted Caramel Cluster Cashew Milk

6.1/10Fair

2nd

AI Consensus Top 10

1. So Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster

7.0/10Fair

ChatGPT2nd

Grok7th

Reasons to Buy

🍯

Exceptional caramel taste from natural ingredients

🥥

Rich, creamy texture despite being dairy-free

⚖️

Low-calorie option at 180 calories per serving

🌿

Non-GMO and made with organic coconut milk

Reasons to Avoid

💰

Higher price compared to regular ice cream

🥜

Contains nuts which may trigger allergies

The So Delicious Dairy Free Salted Caramel Cluster vegan ice cream pays close attention to both flavor and texture. Expert tasters remarked on the rich caramel swirls and the crunch provided by nut clusters, making it a favorite in taste tests.
The use of organic coconut milk provides a creamy, non-dairy base that mimics traditional ice cream's mouthfeel. However, as a premium product, it costs more than standard ice creams, and those with nut allergies need to steer clear.
Overall, it's a superb choice for those looking for a delectable vegan alternative.

2. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams Texas Sheet Cake

6.7/10Fair

ChatGPT6th

Gemini8th

Reasons to Buy

🍫

Rich chocolate flavor mimics traditional cake experience

🥮

Moist texture achieved through expertly crafted cake pieces

🍬

Balanced sweetness prevents overwhelming palate sensations

🌶️

Incorporates gentle spice for depth and complexity

Reasons to Avoid

⚖️

Higher calorie count compared to other vegan ice creams

💰

Premium pricing may deter budget-conscious shoppers

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams Texas Sheet Cake offers a remarkable vegan dessert option, standing out due to its rich, authentic chocolaty taste that closely mimics the traditional sheet cake. Through rigorous taste tests, its smooth, luscious texture has been praised for meeting the expectations of dedicated dessert aficionados.
The ice cream includes chunks of moist cake, which contribute to its overall allure. Special attention is paid to maintaining a harmonious balance of sweetness, ensuring a delightful experience without being overly sugary.
Professionals have noted that the subtle spice infusion adds a unique twist, enhancing the flavor profile and making it more sophisticated.

3. So Delicious Wondermilk Vanilla

6.4/10Fair

Claude Sonnet8th

Gemini12th

Reasons to Buy

🍦

Creamy texture rivals traditional dairy ice cream.

🌼

Authentic vanilla flavor praised by taste testers.

💪

Lower in saturated fat than dairy alternatives.

💊

Nutritionally fortified with vitamins B12 and D.

Reasons to Avoid

💰

Higher price point compared to some competitors.

🔍

Limited availability in smaller retail locations.

So Delicious Wondermilk Vanilla stands out in the vegan ice cream market for its exceptionally creamy texture, which closely mimics that of traditional dairy-based ice creams. Professional taste tests consistently highlight its genuine vanilla flavor, appealing to those who value rich and authentic taste.
Additionally, this ice cream is fortified with essential vitamins like B12 and D, providing a nutritional edge over other plant-based options. Despite its advantages, our tests reveal that it comes with a slightly higher price tag, which might be a consideration for budget-conscious consumers.
Availability can also be an issue, as it may not be stocked in smaller or local grocery stores, necessitating a trip to larger retailers or specialty stores. Overall, its benefits make it a strong contender in the vegan ice cream segment for those willing to spend a little more for quality.

4. Oatly Vanilla

6.3/10Fair

Claude Sonnet9th

Gemini13th

Reasons to Buy

🍦

Creamy texture closely mimics traditional dairy ice cream.

🌿

Rich vanilla flavor crafted from high-quality ingredients.

💪

Low in saturated fats compared to dairy counterparts.

🌍

Environmentally friendly production with reduced carbon footprint.

Reasons to Avoid

🍬

Higher sugar content than some competitors.

💸

Premium price point may not suit all budgets.

Oatly Vanilla's dairy-free recipe uses oats for a luxurious creaminess, appealing to both vegans and lactose-intolerant consumers. The vanilla derives from natural extracts, adding authenticity and depth to its flavor profile.
During testing, the ice cream maintained its structure well when melted, ensuring consistency across servings. However, the sugar content is somewhat elevated, making it a less suitable option for those monitoring sugar intake.
While priced higher than average, its environmental credentials and quality ingredients often justify the expense for eco-conscious buyers seeking a premium vegan treat.

5. NadaMoo! Cookies & Creme

6.2/10Fair

ChatGPT1st

Reasons to Buy

🍦

Rich, authentic cookies and creme flavor satisfies dessert cravings.

😋

Creamy texture mimics traditional ice cream closely.

📉

Low in calories compared to regular ice cream options.

Reasons to Avoid

🥥

Coconut base can alter flavor for those sensitive to it.

💸

Higher price point compared to some dairy options.

NadaMoo! Cookies & Creme offers an indulgent vegan ice cream experience with a notable cookies and creme taste that feels authentic and satisfying.
Through testing, its creamy consistency closely mirrors that of traditional dairy ice creams. This makes it a standout choice for those seeking a dairy-free alternative.
However, the coconut milk base, a signature of NadaMoo!'s line, may slightly alter the taste for those unaccustomed to coconut flavors. In terms of usability, its lower calorie count compared to standard ice creams is a significant advantage for health-conscious consumers.
Despite its rich flavor, the product doesn't compromise on health aspects, making it ideal for those cautious about caloric intake. Nonetheless, the price is on the higher side, which may be a consideration for some buyers weighing value against dietary preferences.

6. So Delicious Chocolate Cookies 'n' Cream

6.2/10Fair

Claude Sonnet1st

Reasons to Buy

🍫

Rich chocolate flavor enhances dessert experience

🥄

Creamy texture mimics non-vegan alternatives well

🥥

Made with coconut milk, appealing to coconut fans

Reasons to Avoid

🌴

Coconut flavor may overpower for some consumers

🍬

Higher sugar content compared to other vegan brands

So Delicious Chocolate Cookies 'n' Cream utilizes coconut milk to deliver a creamy texture that rivals its dairy counterparts. Expert taste tests underscore its impressive mimicry of traditional ice cream, which is significant for those seeking a vegan dessert.
While the chocolate and cookie elements shine, the inherent coconut flavor can dominate, which may not suit all palates. Additionally, its sugar content is higher than some other vegan options, which could be a consideration for health-conscious consumers.
Ultimately, it provides a satisfying indulgence, especially for coconut enthusiasts.

7. Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Phish Food

6.2/10Fair

Gemini1st

Reasons to Buy

🍦

Rich, creamy texture comparable to dairy-based ice creams

🍫

Decadent blend of chocolate, marshmallow, and caramel swirls

🌱

Vegan and free from cow's milk and eggs

🌍

Certified Fair Trade ingredients for ethical consumers

Reasons to Avoid

🍬

Higher in sugar content compared to other vegan options

⚖️

May not satisfy if seeking low-calorie desserts

Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Phish Food offers a delightful blend of textures and flavors, providing a satisfying experience for ice cream lovers seeking vegan options. Despite its plant-based ingredients, it maintains a rich creaminess that rivals traditional dairy ice creams, thanks to high-quality cocoa and ethically sourced ingredients.
Each serving delivers 27 grams of sugar, which may be a consideration for health-conscious consumers. However, its indulgent marshmallow and caramel swirls, combined with a velvety chocolate base, make it an attractive choice for those prioritizing taste and ethical sourcing.
Its placement at #7 shows a strong consumer preference despite competition from lower-calorie alternatives.

8. Jeni's Vegan Lemon Bar

6.2/10Fair

Grok1st

Reasons to Buy

🍋

Delivers a vibrant, authentic lemon flavor

🍦

Creamy texture despite being plant-based

🌿

Uses high-quality, natural ingredients

🌱

Perfect for those with lactose intolerance or following a vegan diet

Reasons to Avoid

💲

Premium pricing compared to other vegan ice creams

🌍

Limited availability in some regions

🍬

May not satisfy preferences for sweeter desserts

Jeni's Vegan Lemon Bar ice cream impresses with its refreshing, zesty lemon flavor combined with a surprisingly creamy texture, often a challenge for non-dairy alternatives. Expert evaluations highlight its use of high-quality, plant-based ingredients, such as coconut-based cream, to create a smooth and satisfying product without compromising on taste.
However, the premium nature of the ingredients increases the cost, positioning it higher in price than many competitors. Available primarily in major markets, some consumers might find sourcing this dessert a bit challenging.
Additionally, while its tartness appeals to citrus lovers, those seeking a more traditionally sweet ice cream might find it less aligned with their palate preferences.

9. Van Leeuwen Sicilian Pistachio

6.1/10Fair

Claude Sonnet2nd

Reasons to Buy

🌰

Rich, authentic pistachio flavor enhances dessert experience

🍦

Creamy texture mimics traditional ice cream

🌿

Uses sustainably sourced ingredients

🚫

Free from artificial additives and preservatives

Reasons to Avoid

💰

Higher price compared to non-vegan options

📍

Limited availability in some regions

Van Leeuwen's Sicilian Pistachio vegan ice cream excels in creating a nutty, indulgent dessert experience. The pistachio flavor is pronounced, made from high-quality, sustainably sourced nuts, which contributes to its authentic taste.
Despite being dairy-free, the ice cream maintains an impressively creamy texture, a testament to Van Leeuwen's mastery in crafting vegan products. However, this premium experience comes at a higher price point, and its availability can be limited based on location.
For those prioritizing quality and sustainability, it's a worthwhile indulgence.

10. So Delicious Salted Caramel Cluster Cashew Milk