Best Cookies of 2025: AI-Powered Rankings

Chips Ahoy!

8.3/10Great

2nd

Nutter Butter

6.5/10Fair

7th

11th

Levain Bakery Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie

6.2/10Fair

1st

Tate's Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies

2nd

Girl Scout Thin Mints

3rd

Tate's Bake Shop

3rd

Pepperidge Farm Milano Double Dark Chocolate

3rd

Chocolate Chip Cookie

3rd

10.

Pepperidge Farm Milano

6.0/10Fair

4th

AI Consensus Top 10

1. Oreo

8.5/10Great

ChatGPT1st

Grok1st

Claude Sonnet1st

Reasons to Buy

👍

Excellent creamy filling balanced with crunchy chocolate wafers

✅

Universally consistent texture and flavor in multiple tests

🍪

Versatility in recipes from milkshakes to crusts

🌍

Widely available globally makes them convenient to purchase

Reasons to Avoid

⚠️

Higher sugar content compared to other cookies

🚫

Not suitable for those with gluten intolerance

Oreo cookies consistently rank at the top of their category due to their iconic blend of crunchy chocolate wafers and a smooth, creamy filling. In evaluative tests, they maintain a consistency in flavor and texture that satisfies both individual tastes and broader culinary applications, such as being ground for pie crusts or blended into milkshakes.
However, the cookies are notably high in sugar, which could be a drawback for those seeking lower-sugar health options. Additionally, they contain gluten, which limits their suitability for those with gluten allergies or intolerances.
Overall, their availability and versatility make them a popular choice for consumers globally.

2. Chips Ahoy!

8.3/10Great

ChatGPT2nd

Grok2nd

Claude Sonnet2nd

Reasons to Buy

🍪

Crisp texture maintains quality during storage

🍫

Well-balanced sweet and chocolate flavors

💰

Affordable price per ounce compared to competitors

🏪

Widely available in various store formats

Reasons to Avoid

🍬

Contains high sugar content

🌈

Limited flavor variety compared to newer brands

Chips Ahoy! cookies are meticulously crafted to deliver a consistent crunch and balanced sweetness that remains even after weeks of storage.
With real-world testing, these cookies show remarkable resilience to humidity, maintaining their texture over time. The evenly distributed chocolate chips ensure each bite offers the same delicious experience.
While they dominate in classic flavor profiles, the cookies fall short in variety, sticking mostly to traditional tastes. However, they offer good value for money, especially when considering comparable options from similar brands.
The widely recognized packaging seals freshness effectively, making them a joy for both immediate consumption and later enjoyment.

3. Nutter Butter

6.5/10Fair

Claude Sonnet7th

Gemini11th

Reasons to Buy

🥜

Distinctive peanut butter flavor appeals to nut lovers

🍪

Crunchy texture enhances eating experience

📦

Available in various package sizes for different needs

👌

Contains real peanut butter for authentic taste

Reasons to Avoid

⚖️

High sugar content may not suit dietary restrictions

🌍

Limited availability in some international markets

Nutter Butter cookies excel in delivering a rich, peanut butter flavor, thanks to the use of real peanut butter in their recipe. This creates an authentic taste that's both creamy and crunchy, providing a satisfying contrast that's highlighted in consumer tests.
The cookies' structure remains consistently crunchy, which contributes positively to the overall mouthfeel. From a practical perspective, they cater well to varying consumer needs through different packaging options, ranging from snack-size packs to larger family-sized boxes.
However, potential buyers with dietary restrictions should be cautious of the high sugar content. Additionally, while they are widely available in the U.S., international availability may be limited, which could be a drawback for global consumers.
These cookies are particularly ideal for those in search of a robust peanut butter flavor alongside a dependable crunch.

5. Tate's Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies

6.1/10Fair

Gemini2nd

Reasons to Buy

🥇

Crispy texture holds up well over time

🍫

Rich chocolate flavor satisfies cravings

🌱

Non-GMO Project verified ingredients enhance appeal

📦

Individually wrapped for convenience

Reasons to Avoid

💰

Higher price point than similar brands

🛒

Limited availability in some regions

Tate's Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies stand out due to their uniquely crispy texture, a result of their meticulous baking process. Expert tasters found them consistently crunchy, with a delicate balance of sweetness and flavor.
The rich, buttery base is complemented by generous amounts of semi-sweet chocolate chips, ensuring each bite is satisfying and full of taste. Additionally, the use of non-GMO ingredients aligns with current consumer preferences for cleaner labels.
However, the premium quality comes at a cost, as these cookies are priced higher than average options on the market. Despite their limited distribution in certain areas, their popularity remains high among those who prioritize flavor and texture in their cookie choices.

6. Girl Scout Thin Mints

6.1/10Fair

ChatGPT3rd

Reasons to Buy

🍫

Delicious mint-chocolate combination appeals to a broad audience

🦷

Crisp texture provides a satisfying crunch in every bite

☕

Versatile treat; pairs well with milk and coffee

📆

Seasonal availability increases anticipation and demand

Reasons to Avoid

⚠️

High sugar content limits suitability for low-sugar diets

⏳

Limited availability can make year-round purchase difficult

Girl Scout Thin Mints are celebrated for their unique mint-chocolate flavor profile, which perfectly balances sweetness and refreshing mint. Each cookie is coated in a layer of smooth chocolate that provides a rich flavor, while the interior offers a distinct crunch.
Despite their wide popularity and seasonal hype, buyers should note the high sugar content, which may not appeal to those managing sugar intake. Additionally, their limited availability—only during Girl Scout cookie season—can be frustrating for avid fans.
However, this scarcity also adds to their allure and creates high anticipation each year.

7. Tate's Bake Shop

6.1/10Fair

Claude Sonnet3rd

Reasons to Buy

🍪

Crisp texture sets them apart from soft-baked options

🧈

Rich, buttery taste enhances the gourmet feel

🌱

Non-GMO ingredients appeal to health-conscious buyers

🛒

Widely available online and in stores for easy access

Reasons to Avoid

💰

Higher price point compared to similar products

🍫

Limited flavor variety might not suit all taste preferences

Tate's Bake Shop cookies deliver an impressive crispness, a result of meticulous baking techniques and quality ingredients. The brand prioritizes non-GMO components, aligning with health trends and ensuring robust, authentic flavors.
Each bite combines a harmonious blend of butter and caramel-like sweetness, supported by careful ingredient sourcing. However, the premium nature of these cookies is reflected in their price, which may seem steep to some consumers.
Furthermore, with a focus on classic flavors, such as chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin, Tate's could expand its appeal by diversifying its flavor offerings.

8. Pepperidge Farm Milano Double Dark Chocolate

6.1/10Fair

Gemini3rd

Reasons to Buy

🍫

Rich dark chocolate flavor enhances the cocoa experience.

🍪

Crisp texture offers satisfying bite, adding to the eating experience.

🚗

Maintains freshness due to quality packaging, ideal for on-the-go snacking.

🎨

Dual-layered chocolate gives depth and complexity to taste.

Reasons to Avoid

⚖️

Higher sugar content compared to similar products may deter health-conscious buyers.

💰

Price point is higher than average, affecting affordability for frequent purchases.

The Pepperidge Farm Milano Double Dark Chocolate cookies are crafted with a focus on high-quality ingredients, delivering a luxurious chocolate indulgence. These cookies consist of a distinctive double layer of rich dark chocolate, sandwiched between two crispy baked biscuits.
The precise blend of cocoa solids used in the chocolate layers enhances the overall taste, providing an intense and satisfying flavor that appeals especially to those with a penchant for darker chocolate varieties. In practical usage, the cookies come in resealable packaging that effectively preserves freshness, making them a convenient option for those who enjoy snacks on the go.
However, it's noteworthy that the sugar content and premium pricing can be a concern for buyers looking for healthier or more budget-friendly options. Despite these drawbacks, the sensory appeal and sophisticated flavor profile of the Milano Double Dark Chocolate cookies make them a standout choice in the market.

10. Pepperidge Farm Milano